Student Forums CIA Part 2: Practice of Internal Auditing Section III: Performing the Engagement Meaning of example in “Extrapolating variables sampling results ..” section

Meaning of example in “Extrapolating variables sampling results ..” section

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #231335

    This forum is restricted to members of the associated course(s).

    This forum is restricted to members of the associated course(s).

    Denny Benjamin
    Participant

    Hi Brian, 

    In the example, what does the sampling result mean to the auditor when auditing the $4.5 million and 4K customers accounts receivable balance?

    Mean per unit — $4.8 million

    Difference estimation — $4.9 million

    Ratio method — $4.905 million

    Are the customer accounts under valued?  

    What is audited value?  How does $220,000 increase to $240,000?

     

    Thanks,

    Denny

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #231340

    This forum is restricted to members of the associated course(s).

    Brian Hock
    HOCK international

    Hello, Denny,

    The audited value is the correct value of the items they tested. They audited 200 accounts and those 200 accounts had an actual (audited) value of $240,000. Those same accounts were recorded on the books for $220,000. So, there was a $20,000 difference between the recorded value (book) and the actual (audited) value. Since they tested 200 accounts, the average misstatement was $100 ($20,000 / 200). So, we assume that all of the accounts are understood by $100. Since there are 4,000 accounts, we calculate that in total, they understatement is $400,000 ($100 per each account x 4,000 accounts).

    Yes, on the books, the customer accounts have been undervalued. And this is the estimation of how much they have all been undervalued. We use the testing that we did on 200 accounts to estimate the total undervaluation of all 4,000 accounts.

    Does this help?

    Brian

    #231354

    This forum is restricted to members of the associated course(s).

    Denny Benjamin
    Participant

    Hi Brian,

    It helps.

    What could be the reasons for understatement of balances?  Not recording a credit sale, excessive write offs, ….

    Thanks, 

    Denny 

    #231370

    This forum is restricted to members of the associated course(s).

    Brian Hock
    HOCK international

    Denny,

    It could be as simple as a mistake. It could be that they have misreported discounts. There could have been something about accounts being written off incorrectly. The system was not recording all of the invoices, the system was not making calculations correctly. There could be any number of reasons, but in the context of this question, it is how the misstatement is calculated that is what is important.

    Brian

Viewing 3 replies - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)

This forum is restricted to members of the associated course(s).

  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.